PR19 – KPMG criticises Ofwat’s market-based approach to cost of equity

September 10, 2017

A KPMG report for Anglian Water, Affinity Water and Northumbrian Water has argued the regulator has made a “fundamental change” to the way it estimates the ‘total market return’ (TMR), a key component of the cost of equity. This relates to Ofwat’s use of a “a market based cost of equity, placing less weight on long-run historical average equity returns, and in fact places no weight on their estimates of actual, outturn historical returns”.


Based on PwC analysis, Ofwat’s market based approach has produced a cost of equity range of 3.8% to 4.5% on a real RPI basis, compared to 5.65% at PR14. KPMG pointed out: “PwC estimates a nominal cost of equity range of 6.7% to 7.4%, based on a nominal TMR of 8% to 8.5%, significantly below long-term market estimates of 10.3%. Ofwat’s own estimates for TMR in PR09 were 6.75% in real terms compared to their current estimate of 5.1%-5.5% TMR (real). This again marks a significant shift from their previous determinations of TMR.”


KPMG concluded: “Relying on short-term estimates would introduce substantial financial risk to the firms and investors on the basis of assumptions which cannot be relied upon.”


Coming soon – THE WATER REPORT's comprehensive analysis of the PR 19 consultation.


Please reload

Featured Posts

Advisor urges Sunak to unlock private infrastructure capital to reboot economy

May 24, 2020

Please reload

More from this week
Please reload